June 16, 2016

In this week’s sedra Abarbanel addresses the age old problem of how, after taking them out of Egyptian slavery and giving them the Torah, both amid open miracles, the Israelites still complain and misbehave regularly.

Chapter eleven in this Torah portion begins with a very enigmatic verse: “And the people were like complainers; evil in the ears of God, and God heard and his wrath flared and a fire of God burned against them, and it consumed at the edge of the camp”.

Curiously, they are not referred to simply as “complainers”. Rather, they are described as “like complainers”. Furthermore, we are not told what they were complaining about.

Abarbanel explains that despite the fact that Jewish People had spent an entire year at Sinai where they had received the Torah with its teachings and Divine admonitions, they never really abandoned the heretical beliefs that they had absorbed in Egypt. Similarly, they had imitated the crass Egyptian character, especially in regard to eating and drinking. Here, at Sinai, in a place where the Divine Torah should have straightened out their crooked beliefs and character, the Egyptian influence still could not be completely erased. Despite the fact that they were accompanied by the Ark of the Covenant and led by the Clouds of Glory, the two episodes that begin this chapter illustrate the failure of belief and character which remained with them.

The Hebrew word that is usually translated as “complainers” actually means, in the context of our text, “those who sought a pretext to complain”. Abarbanel then transfigures the rest of the verse so that it reads as follows: “They sought pretexts to prove that God’s ears were bad”; that is to say, that God did not pay attention to the everyday words and actions of the people.

This is similar to the verse in Psalms 94:7: “And they said that God will not see, God will not understand.” Their belief was that God was not aware of and did not relate to the details of everyday, lowly physical existence. They expressed this belief now because Moshe had just said in the previous verse (10:36): “Arise, God, and let Your foes be scattered, let those who hate You flee from before You. And when it (the Ark) rested, he (Moshe) would say, ‘Reside tranquilly, O, God, among the myriad thousands of Israel’.”

The people were essentially mocking Moshe’s words. They didn’t believe that God really resided amongst them, that He was attuned to them. Yet they are still described as like those looking for a pretext because they were not totally denying the concept of Divine Providence. They understood that it applied to well-known and publicized miraculous interventions in nature. Rather, they were looking for a pretext to deny God’s providence in regard to the details of everyday life.

Since their transgression does involve an overtly public action, the Torah does not go into further detail. Rather, to counter their claim that God does not hear, the Torah says explicitly that God heard. To counter their claim that God was not personally involved on an individual basis, God made sure that they would recognize Him through the punishment of fire, which was directed miraculously and specifically against only those who were guilty. The fire burned only on the “edge” of the camp, indicating that it was a miraculous fire, not a natural one which would have normally spread further. The people cried out to Moshe, who then prayed to God. To further demonstrate the uniquely personal and providential nature of the fire, it was then immediately absorbed into the ground.

Shabbat shalom


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s